|
| The Children of Hurin | 
 enlarge
| Author: J.r.r. Tolkien
Creators: Christopher Tolkien, Alan Lee
Publisher: HarperCollins Publishers Ltd
Category: Book
List Price: £18.99
Buy Used: £1.62
You Save: £17.37 (91%)
New (22) Collectible (7) from £3.80
Avg. Customer Rating:  56 reviews
Sales Rank: 20713
Media: Hardcover
Edition: New Ed
Pages: 313
Shipping Weight (lbs): 1.3
Dimensions (in): 8.7 x 6.1 x 1.5
ISBN: 0007246226
EAN: 9780007246229
ASIN: 0007246226
Publication Date: April 17, 2007
Availability: Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days
Condition: SUPER FAST SHIPPING, DISPATCHED SAME DAY FROM UK WAREHOUSE. NO NEED TO WAIT FOR BOOKS FROM USA. GREAT BOOK IN GOOD OR BETTER CONDITION. MORE GREAT BARGAINS IN OUR ZSHOP. amazon.co.uk/shops/awesome_books_001
|
| Also Available In:
|
| Similar Items:
|
| Customer Reviews: Read 51 more reviews...
 re-hashing for profit September 21, 2008
0 out of 2 found this review helpful
if you already have "unfinished tales" then you already own this book , give or take a few editorial tweaks......Tolkien is become a rip-off industry
Unreadable August 30, 2008
0 out of 3 found this review helpful
Okay, I've read The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings and thought they were fantastic, but this was just terrible. I couldn't get past the first chapter. The prose is dreadful "so and so (unpronouncable name) "was the son of so-and so" (another unpronouncable name) "decended from so-and so" (again unprnouncable) - you get the idea. Just unreadable, turgid rubbish. You'll need the patience of a saint to get through this. Really, life's too short to waste on this ponderous bore-a-thon. Avoid! Avoid! Avoid!
Not Your Father's Hurin August 24, 2008
2 out of 2 found this review helpful
This is a tale of unrelenting tragedy. Drawn from the history of the First Age of Middle-earth, it tells of how Morgoth, the original Dark Lord to whom Sauron was but a lieutenant, wreaked appalling vengeance upon the family of the man Hurin, chiefly for his refusal to betray a great hidden city of the elves who were his allies. Readers acquainted with the story from a more summary version published three decades earlier in THE SILMARILLION will have some idea what to expect. They will also understand the part these events ultimately did play in the fall of virtually every elven kingdom in the vast land of Beleriand before it sank beneath the sea, still millennia prior to the events recounted in THE LORD OF THE RINGS.
This new telling, however, differs from the former in at least two respects. First and most obvious, it greatly develops the details so that we come to know the doomed players more intimately, better appreciating both their flaws and their virtues, and thus feeling the tragedy more personally when it manifests itself in turn after turn of their lives.
Second and perhaps more subtle is what this version leaves out. THE SILMARILLION continued the story further, revealing later events which, while not negating these present disasters, at least mitigated them somewhat, suggesting that evil's triumph was indeed only for a season. (There were also poignant touches, such as the extraordinary future of a certain gravesite, which lent a melancholy beauty to the sorrow.) Here, however, Christopher Tolkien, the author's son and editor, chooses to end the tale at a point which before had occurred in mid-paragraph. When I first glanced through HURIN and then reacquainted myself with the earlier publication, I seriously questioned this decision.
It has been said that part of Shakespeare's genius in writing his own tragedies was his choice to abstain from moralization. Rarely did the Bard attempt to explain a character's fate in terms of what he or she ought to have done, or of some divine wisdom which, if glimpsed, might explain or even vindicate the suffering. Shakespeare simply showed tragedy with all the seemingly pointless capriciousness of real life, and left it to his audience to speculate further.
Tolkien was not Shakespeare, however. While even THE HOBBIT and LOTR are haunted by melancholy and a sense of loss, Tolkien believed in a transcendent Sovereignty and argued eloquently for some element in such tales which, however faintly, foreshadowed a distant 'Eucatastrophe' (i.e., happy ending) to come, 'giving a fleeting glimpse of Joy, Joy beyond the walls of the world, poignant as grief.' By cutting off the story of Hurin's family where he does, Christopher denies it that consolation.
Having said this, I must make a confession: When I had read HURIN through properly from the beginning and came again to the final two pages, I broke down and sobbed. The same juncture had had no such impact on me in THE SILMARILLION. I may prefer the elder Tolkien's tempering of tragedy with hope and question the philosophical implications of ending this story so abruptly; yet I can not deny that doing so made the bitterness of that end immeasurably more powerful. For a moment I FELT the despair of those who had endured such relentless doom, who left the world knowing nothing of some vaguely conceived consolation in the far future. While that moment lasted, for me their suffering had become very real.
If there is, as Tolkien believed, a 'Joy beyond the walls of the world', the heartbreaking fact remains that there are those who live and die and, for any number of reasons, fail utterly to apprehend it. Consolation may be, yet some are never consoled. THE CHILDREN OF HURIN is not a pleasant book, yet it captures something of the seeming futility in which so many souls have passed through the world. At the least, it reminds those who find and live in hope not to grow callous toward those who are cheated of it.
 Not Tolkien's more memorable piece of works...... June 24, 2008
0 out of 3 found this review helpful
Yes Tolkien's son has done a good job of presenting the book and explaining as much as he can. Furthermore Alan Lee's drawings are, as always, top drawer. However I thought the story was depressing and the number of names/characters used started to annoy me. I never ended up caring about any of the characters. Overall average.
im sorry but it is a disgusting concept - utterly dissapointed!!!! June 15, 2008
0 out of 20 found this review helpful
i was just about to but the book when i actually read the synopsis from encarta and was shocked to know that turin and his sister end up unintentionally marrying each other - thats incest!!!!! ewwwwww i physically felt sick honestly....
the story is not really related to the LOTR and it was soooo hamlet like tragedy which put me off as im a big fan of the hobbit and LOTR....
anyways i didnt wish to buy the book anymore... im gonna wait till the silmarillion comes out as that is more related to the forging of the rings!
|
|
|
Powered by Associate-O-Matic
| |
